Dresser & Associates is Now Part of Net@Work!
X
Net@Work | Dresser & Associates
We are extremely pleased to announce that Dresser & Associates has joined Net@Work, one of the most respected Sage Software Partners in North America and an award-winning end-to-end technology solutions provider. You will see very little change relative to your Sage Software support, really just a name change.

Our existing staff will all be joining Net@Work and will continue to provide the excellent level of service and support our customers have come to expect. Our entire team is very excited about joining Net@Work and the ability to bring even more knowledge and resources to all of our clients.

Thank you for your continued business and we look forward to our ongoing relationship.

Mark F. Dresser, Dresser & Associates, Inc | mfdresser@dresserassociates.com
Read Message from Mark Dresser | Read the Full Press Release | Visit Us at www.netatwork.com
Dresser & Associates
GoToAssist

Contingent Staffing

Employee vs. Independent Contractor: A Game of 20 Questions

In today's economic climate, downsizing is an unfortunate reality for many businesses. Despite staff reductions, a company must continue to produce if it is to survive long term. While contingent staffing may seem like a logical way to get the work done—and keep headcount and associated employment costs such as taxes and benefits down—think twice before engaging the services of an “independent contractor” (IC).

Simply because (a) you refer to a worker as an IC, (b) he or she has agreed to the arrangement in a written contract, and (c) payments are issued by accounts payable rather than the payroll department does not mean that the individual is, in fact, an IC. The nature of the relationship between the individual and the company is the true determinant, and misclassification can result in serious consequences for an organization. These consequences include back-paying taxes; retroactively providing benefits, including vacation pay, stock options and 401(K) contributions; and stiff financial penalties.

There are a number of events that may trigger an investigation into your worker classification practices. For example, a contingent worker may apply for unemployment benefits at the conclusion of his or her contract, make a complaint of discrimination or harassment, or file a workers' compensation claim. In addition, the IRS may target the organization for an audit either randomly or in response to a sudden and significant change in the number of reported W-2 employees.

The specific criteria used to discern whether an individual is an employee or an IC depends upon which government agency is researching the situation. Beware: It is not uncommon for one office to get others involved, and their conclusions are not always consistent.

The focus of any such inquiry is the level of control that the employer holds over the individual. It is important to note that whether this control is actually exerted is irrelevant; what really matters is whether the employer could, if it so desired, dictate the details of the individual's work.

The Internal Revenue Service's 20-Factor Control Test is the most explicit in its requirements. The good news is that no single factor is decisive. Rather, the facts and circumstances surrounding all of them must be carefully considered when assessing the degree of control that exists in a given work arrangement.

When determining whether an individual is more appropriately classified as an employee or IC, ask the following questions:

  
YES
NO
1. Is the individual's work vital to the company's core business? Employee activities are integrated with the organization's business operations. IC services typically are limited to non-essential business activities.
2. Did the company train the individual to perform tasks in a specific way? Employees usually are taught the specific work procedures that they are expected to follow and must comply with any other employer requirements with regard to these activities. ICs generally are considered "experts" in their field and, as such, can determine which work methods are most appropriate. Additionally, they typically are held accountable only for outcomes, not the means with which they are achieved.
3. Do you (or can you) instruct the individual as to when, where, and how the work is performed?      
4. Do you (or can you) control the sequence or order of the work performed?      
5. Do you (or can you) set the hours of work for the individual? Employees generally work on a schedule determined by their employer. ICs can work whatever hours they choose, provided that agreed-upon deadlines are met.
6. Do you (or can you) require the individual to perform the work personally? Employees must do the tasks for which they were hired themselves. ICs are free to delegate to their own staff or subcontract the work to others.
7. Do you (or can you) prohibit the individual from hiring, supervising, and paying assistants?      
8. Does the individual perform regular and continuous services for you? Employees typically have an open-ended relationship with a company, even if the work is performed at irregular intervals. ICs work on a project-by-project basis, each time with a new contract.
9. Does the individual provide services on a substantially full-time basis to your company? Employees usually are expected to devote all working hours to their employer. ICs do not spend so much time with any one company that they are restricted from doing projects for others and, in fact, generally work for multiple clients concurrently.
10. Is the company the sole or major source of income for the individual?      
11. Is the work performed on your premises? Employees ordinarily are required to work on-site. ICs are free to work off-site, such as in a home office.
12. Do you (or can you) require the individual to submit regular reports, either written or oral? Employees may be asked to provide status or activity reports on a regular basis. ICs are responsible for producing a final deliverable and are not, therefore, required to provide interim reports.
13. Does the company pay the individual by the hour, week, or month? Employees usually are paid at fixed intervals. ICs generally are paid for their results, not the amount of time worked.
14. Does the company pay the individual's travel and business expenses? Employees who incur work-related expenses typically are reimbursed by their employer. ICs usually are expected to incorporate out-of-pocket expenses into their project fee rather than be directly reimbursed for them.
15. Are tools or equipment furnished for the individual? Employees generally use company-provided supplies. ICs are expected to own and use their own supplies.
16. Does the individual have a significant investment in facilities, tools or equipment? Employees typically use their company's facilities, tools and equipment. ICs incur expenses related to work space, equipment, etc., like any other business owner.
17. Can the individual realize a profit or loss from his or her services to the company? Employees usually can expect steady paychecks ICs run the risk of non-payment if a project is not completed according to the specifications detailed in the contract.
18. Does the individual make his or her services available to the general public? Employees typically do not position and market themselves as service providers. ICs publicize their services to a wide range of potential clients via direct mail, advertising, etc.
19. Can the individual terminate the relationship without liability? Employees can quit at any time and can typically be released "at will" by their employers. ICs legally are obligated to complete projects according to contract provisions and can be dismissed only if they fail to do so.
20. Does the company have the right to discharge the individual at any time?      

Do these 20 factors make it clear if the worker is an employee or not? Not always! There is currently federal legislation proposed to create IRS code to replace the 20-factor common law test with a supposedly simpler Internal Revenue Code. While this may or may not happen, the above factors are still practical questions for employers considering how to classify and use contingent staff.

Contingent Staffing Guidelines

In addition to the above factors and guidelines, a company can further differentiate between employees and contingent staff by other types of tangible and intangible treatment. Human resource professionals have long counseled managers on the care and treatment of employees. When it comes to contingent staff, care and treatment must be carefully handled. Contingent staff are not employees of the company and should not be entitled to or eligible for many company programs and events. It is critical for the company to recognize contingent workers as employees of a contingent-type agency or as independent contractors. As such, the company should not provide the following to a contingent worker:

  • Company business cards.
  • Company credit cards.
  • Letters of recommendation.
  • Name plates.
  • Company stationary.

The following types of programs should be handled by the contingent worker's employer and not by the company:

  • Recreational or social activities.
  • Performance appraisals, salary adjustments, employee benefits.
  • Disciplinary action.
  • EEO/harassment policies, procedures and interpretation.
  • Recognition programs.
  • Training.
  • Travel.

Of the above items, the final two, training and travel, are more blurred in nature. Generally, generic training that is available to the public, and on-going developmental training should be the responsibility of the contingent workers and/or their employer. The company should provide any training that is specific in nature and required to successfully complete the job assignments. This often includes machine or specific software training or site-specific safety training. If a contingent worker will be required to travel during the course of their assignment, his or her employer should be responsible for all costs, reservations and reimbursements. The company should provide adequate notice and information to the appropriate employer.

In addition, the company should provide information on specific work-related policies and procedures contingent workers need to be aware of during their job assignment. These may include parking, building access, ID badges, smoking, phone systems, e-mail and other communication systems, solicitation, dress code, safety, company culture and conduct, and confidentiality and non-disclosure.

Conclusion

Employers must be aware of the ramifications involved with the use of contingent workers. There are ways to minimize the risks involved, specifically by knowing the legal and common-law landscape, using external vendors such as temporary and contract firms, and developing and enforcing company policy on the care and treatment of company employees and contingent workers. As we all continue to fight in the war for talent, having a staffing toolkit designed to provide the utmost in flexibility will go a long way toward ensuring the company's success and growth.

Article by Susan Burleigh, SPHR, of the SHRM Employment Committee, from http://www.shrm.org/

  • Overview
  • Associations
    • Associations
    • Talent Management and Employee Retention
    • Employee Relations and Employee Benefits
    • Training and Development
    • Compliance and Legal Help
    • Business Management
    • Payroll
  • State & Federal Government
    • State & Federal Links
    • Law
    • US Department of Labor Links
    • OSHA
    • Government Printing Office
    • Federal/State Tax Information
    • HIPAA
    • Federal Tax Calculators/Reporting Forms
    • Safety
    • Articles on Diversity & Affirmative Action
    • Affordable Care Act
  • General/Miscellaneous
    • HR Websites
    • Recruitment Websites
    • Talent Management Sites
    • Payroll and Taxes
    • HR/Payroll Newsletters
    • Training, Development, and Software Websites
  • HR Metrics
    • HR Metrics
  • HR/Payroll Challenges Solved
    • Cyber Security
    • Human Resources
    • Recruitment & Staffing
    • Compensation & Payroll
    • Compliance
    • Talent Management
  • Magazines
    • Human Resources
    • Benefits
    • Payroll
    • Recruitment & Performance Management
    • General Business
  • Training Development & Talent Management
    • Training & Development Articles
    • Talent Management
  • Payroll/Wage Hour/Compensation/Benefits
    • Payroll Articles
    • Wage Tax Info
    • Employee Benefits
    • Articles on Severance Pay
    • Records and Reporting
  • Recruitment/Staffing/Job Boards
    • Job Boards
    • Hiring Articles
    • Contingent Staffing Articles
    • Relocation
  •  
  • Overview
    • Hey Dresser, Make my job easier!
    • Sage HRMS Video -- The Solution for a New Era of HR
    • HRMS - More Than Just an Administrative Tool
    • ROEI: Return on Employee Investment
    • I want a solution to...
    • Assessing Your Needs
    • What's New
    • Sage HRMS Overview
    • Why Sage HRMS?
    • Comparison
    • What is an HRIS?
    • HRIS Checklist
  •  
  •  
  • Software & Services
    • Sage HRMS Overview
      • Take a Tour
      • Deployment Options
      • Product Briefs and Feature Sheets
    • Sage HRMS
      • Employee Self Service
      • Benefits Enrollment
      • OrgPlus
      • Train
      • Crystal Dashboard
    • Time and Attendance
      • Sage Time and Attendance by Insperity
    • Sage HRMS Extensions
      • Multi-Lingual ESS
      • HR Actions
      • Alerts and Workflow
      • Benefits Messenger
      • Sage Add-Ons and Utilities
      • My Workforce Analyzer (ACA)
    • Payroll
      • Sage Tax Filing Services
      • Outsourced Payroll Options - Sage Payroll Services
    • Recruiting
      • Cyber Recruiter & Cyber Train
      • Hyrell
    • Sage HRMS Talent Management
      • Learning Management
      • Performance Management
      • Cornerstone Product Demos and Flash Videos
      • Cornerstone Success Stories
      • Cornerstone Video Success Stories
      • Feature Sheets
      • PerformancePAM
    • Accounting Integration
      • Accounting Integration Software
      • Timberline Integration
  •  
  •  
  • Support & Training
    • Dresser Support
    • Support Programs
    • Sage Customer Portal
    • Sage Employer Resources
    • Contact Support
    • Free Webinars and Online Training
  •  
  •  
  • Total Care
    • Total Care Program Resources
      • Free Webinars and Online Training
      • Month by Month Training Calendar
      • Dresser & Associates Customer Portal
      • Payroll Resource Center
      • Tips & Tricks
      • User Group Conferences
      • Alliance for Workforce Management
      • HR Management Blog
      • Connect with us on Social Media
      • Newsletters
      • HR Best Practices and Whitepapers
      • Knowledge Center
      • Affordable Care Act
      • HR Selection Tools
    • Partners and Alliances
      • HR & Payroll Forms
      • Take Advantage of Tax Credits
      • Sage HRMS Payroll Tax Forms and eFiling
      • Purchasing Power (premier employee purchase program)
      • Background Screening Services
  •  
  •  
  • Special Offers
    • Affordable Care Act Survival Kit
    • Switch from Sage Abra Suite to Sage HRMS
    • 2015 Year End Closing with Sage Payroll
    • Sage HRMS Benefits Messenger - Electronic Carrier Connections
    • HR & Payroll Forms
    • Sage Alerts and Workflow
    • Dresser & Associates Total Care Program
    • E-Verify
    • Health Plan Information on 2012 W-2's
    • Pennsylvania ACT 32
    • Sage ERP Promotional Offer
    • Cost of a Bad Hire
    • The Power of Partnership
    • Lower Payroll Processing Costs
    • Sage Timberline Payroll Integration
    • Multi-Lingual Employee Self Service Tools
    • Social HR: How Social Collaboration can make Employees more Productive
    • Preparing for OFCCP Compliance
  •  
  •  
  • Company
    • Contact Us
    • What Makes Dresser Different?
    • Referral Rewards Program
    • Client Testimonials
    • Press Releases
    • Associations
    • Awards & Recognition
  •  
  •  
  • Blog
  •  
  •  
  • Customer Portal Login
  •  

BE THE FIRST TO KNOW SIGN UP FOR THE LATEST NEWS

Effective Design, Implementation & Support to meet your HRMS needs

  • HR Software
  • Demo Center
  • Support & Training
  • HRIS Selection Tools
  • Knowledge Center
  • Resources
  • News & Events
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Site Map
  • Legal
Sage Chairman's Club Sage Authorized Partner

Dresser & Associates is a leading provider of HR Software & Payroll Solutions to New England, the Mid Atlantic, South East and Gulf Coast.

243 U.S. Route 1, Scarborough, Maine 04074 | Toll Free: 866-885-7212 | ssoiireeortnscf.eoca@amssd

Regional Offices: Maine | Pennsylvania | Georgia | Florida

© Copyright 2021 Dresser & Associates, Inc.